MLB The Show 23 is now available, bringing a ton of new content and updated player rankings. This year's roster includes a ton of highly ranked players, including four players currently sitting at a 99 Overall rating, the highest possible rating. The following list is ranked by Overall Rating, putting together the 10 highest ranked players. Here are the best players in MLB The Show 23.

10. Bryce Harper - 95 - Philadelphia Phillies

Taking the number 10 spot on the list is Bryce Harper, an outfielder/DH for the Philadelphia Phillies. Despite missing sometime last season due to injury, Harper is still one of the best hitters in the league and a former MVP winner. The main stat lines contributing to his Overall ranking of 95 is a 94 in Contact R and a 98 in Power R, along with an 80 Arm.

9. Max Scherzer - 96 - New York Mets

Max Scherzer, a starting pitcher for the New York Mets, takes the 9th spot on the list with a 96 Overall rating. Former three-time Cy Young winner, Scherzer pitched 23 games in the 2022 Season, finishing with a 11-5 record and an ERA of 2.29. In MLB The Show 23, he has a 99 in Break, 92 in Stamina, and an 89 in H/9, contributing to his Overall of 96, despite being on the older end of pitchers at 38.